« Previous Next »

Page :« 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 ALL»

The most important variable in the study was the choice of cleaners. The team investigated fifteen possible cleaners for inclusion in the study. Possible cleaners are shown in Table 1. The chemical action of these cleaners includes acids, bases, alcohols, chelating agents, solvents, surfactants, and bactericides.

Acids and bases are strong chemical cleaners that work on the basis of the pH of the product. Products such as the Stone Kleen contain ammonium bifloride that easily converts to hydrofluoric acid, a strong acid that can chemically etch and potentially damage the surface of a stone. On the other end of the spectrum is the Kandu product, a low foaming cleaner containing sodium hydroxide, a basic compound.

Alcohols work on the basis of dissolving dirt and grease. They tend to evaporate quickly and are less likely to leave chemical residues. They may be one component of a multicomponent cleaning system. Four of the products, including World Environmental group Marble Cleaner, incorporate alcohols into their formulas.

Chelating agents work on the premise that the cleaner will bind the dirt or grime to itself in order to remove the soiling. Some products containing chelating agents include Stone Quest, Zep-A-One, and World Environmental Group Multi Surface Cleaner 1000.

Solvents work similarly to alcohols in that they dissolve the soiling and may be a component of a more complex cleaning system. Only the product GK125 is listed as a solvent-based cleaner. Solvents are incorporated into some of the other cleaning systems.

Surfactants are wetting agents that lower the surface tension on a liquid allowing for easier spreading. Surfactants also allow grease and oils to be diluted and mixed into water and washed away. They are commonly found in cleaning detergents. Stone Quest, Multi Surface Cleaner 1000, Zep-A-One, World Environmental Group Marble Cleaner, D/2, Kodak Photo-Flo, and Kodak Hypo Clear all contain surfactants.

Bactericides are chemicals that kill bacteria and are commonly found in disinfectants, antiseptics, or antibiotics. One group of bactericides contain cationic surfactants such as quarternary ammonium cations. The D/2 product is an example of a bactericide containing quaternary ammonium cations. Another group of bactericides contain strong acids. Stone-Kleen is an example of a strong acid bactericide.

Product Name
acidic basic alcohol chelate solvent surfactant bactericide
Stone Quest
Stone Care International
X X
GK125
Geokleen Inc.
X
Multi Surface Cleaner
1000
World Environmental
Group, Inc.
X X X
Omni-Green
National Plastics and
Chemical Corp.
Stone-Kleen
Mid Atlantic Chemical
X X
H2Orange2 Grout Safe
Proven Solutions
X
Hurricane Intensive Stone
Cleaner
National Chemical
Laboratories
X X
Zep-A-One
Zep Manufacturing, Co.
X X X
Marble Cleaner
World Environmental
Group, Inc
X X X X
Kandu #110
SpaceAge Coating
Concepts, Inc.
X
Daybreak
NCH Corporation,
Certified Labs
X
D/2
Sunshine Makers, Inc.
X X
Sodium Bicarbonate
Kodak Photo-Flo
Kodak Corporation
X X X
Hypo Clear
Kodak Corporation
X X X

Table 1. A listing of chemical cleaners considered for testing, including main

The five cleaners chosen for inclusion in the study are shown in Table 2. The team wished to include cleaners that were environmentally friendly, user friendly, and were unlikely to damage the stone. Cleaners containing strong acids and bases, such as Stone- Kleen and Kandu, were eliminated on this basis. Daybreak was the most commonly used cleaner within the NCA, and thus was included in the study. H2Orange Grout Safe was chosen to represent an acidic cleaner containing citric acid. D/2 Antimicrobial cleaner was chosen as a bactericide and cleaner. The team felt that the two products by the World Environmental Group were very similar in nature and relied on surfactants and chelating agents. The World Environmental Group Marble (WEG Marble Cleaner) was chosen for inclusion in the study. The final cleaner selected was the Kodak Photo-Flo because of its common use in the cemetery cleaning world. Table 3 shows the range of pH values found for the products chosen for the study.

Table 2. A listing of chemical cleaners chosen for the study, including published pH and component ingredients.
Table 2. A listing of chemical cleaners chosen for the study, including published pH and component ingredients.

Cleaner H2Orange2 Grout Safe Kodak Photo-Flo D-2 Marble Cleaner Daybreak
pH 3.81 7 9.5 10.5 12.1

Table 3. Chosen Cleaners are ordered from Acidic to Basic.

« Previous Next »

Page :« 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 ALL»

Share →

One Response to Comparative Study of Commercially Available Cleaners for Use on Federally-Issued Headstones

  1. Nancy Scheer says:

    June 22, 2010

    I am interested in knowing if anyone has done any investigation into the affect of wet grass & weeds, thrown by lawn mowers onto tombstones?
    Does this cause some of the biological growths we see on tombstones?
    I see this often in cemeteries particularily when the grass has been cut early in the morning while it is still wet.

    Is there any data & results showing a “diluted solution of ammonia” for cleaning tombstones? I believe I read where it is not very effective on biological growth, but is it a recommended product for general cleaning of headstones?

    When using D2 do the rules apply that say only clean tombstones once every 10+ yrs? Where did this rule come from? I just read it on one of the National Preservations of tombstones sites. Is there data to back this rule?

    Has there been any conclusion to the National Cemetery Headstone Cleaning Project and if so where can I find the results?

    Thank you for any consideration you give to these questions.

    Nancy Scheer
    (a volunteer tombstone cleaner in Missouri)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>